
An entrepreneur wants to establish a company in the United States. A family wants their children to study and live in the United States. An investor wants to acquire additional international residence rights. These three objectives may lead to three entirely different strategies — and not every strategy should begin with a green card.
For many Vietnamese families, a United States green card has long been regarded as a symbol of international success.
It represents the right to live long term in one of the world's largest economies, with access to its educational environment, labor market, and new opportunities for growth.
But when working with entrepreneurs who hold assets and operate businesses in multiple countries, a strategic question needs to be asked before choosing an immigration program:
If someone does not genuinely plan to live in the United States long term, is a green card the most suitable solution?
This question is not intended to dismiss the value of United States permanent resident status.
On the contrary, precisely because a green card carries substantial legal value, its accompanying obligations also deserve serious consideration.
1. Wanting to do business in the United States does not mean wanting to settle in the United States

Consider a Vietnamese entrepreneur who runs a manufacturing company with stable revenue.
He wants to expand into the United States market, establish a subsidiary, recruit a sales team, and build relationships with distributors.
His family still lives in Vietnam. Manufacturing operations, most of his assets, and the management team also remain in Vietnam.
In this case, the immediate objective is business expansion, not necessarily relocating the entire family's place of residence.
Establishing a legal entity in the United States, signing contracts with partners, or owning shares in a United States business does not automatically require the owner to hold a green card.
However, if he wants to go to the United States to work and manage the company in person, appropriate immigration status becomes a separate issue.
One option that may be considered is L-1A, for managers or executives transferred within a business organization with a qualifying relationship between its United States and foreign operations.
But L-1A is not simply a visa issued to anyone who has the money to establish a company in the United States.
The business and the transferee must meet specific requirements concerning corporate relationships, work experience, managerial roles, and business operations.
The important point is to distinguish business ownership rights, the right to work in the United States, and the right to permanent residence in the United States. These are three separate legal matters.
2. L-1A and EB-1C: Two potentially related stages, but not an automatic promise
For Vietnamese businesses with genuine plans to expand into the United States, L-1A and EB-1C are often discussed together.
L-1A is a nonimmigrant visa category for managers or executives transferred within a qualifying corporate group or business organization.
EB-1C is an immigrant category for multinational managers or executives that can lead to permanent resident status if the statutory requirements are met and immigration procedures are completed.
These two categories have some similar requirements, but they cannot be treated as equivalent.
In particular, a newly established business in the United States may consider an L-1A application under the new office provisions if it meets the eligibility requirements. For EB-1C, however, the US business must have been actively doing business for at least one year before filing the petition.
This creates a strategic distinction.
A plan to establish a company in the United States cannot be designed solely to meet the initial application requirements. The business must be capable of developing substantive operations, building an organization and sustaining an appropriate managerial role.
A company that exists on paper, without significant business activity, does not automatically become an eligible foundation for EB-1C.
The important question, therefore, is not:
“Can a company be established to apply for L-1A?”
It is:
“Does the business have sufficient commercial rationale, resources and an operating plan to sustain itself in the United States, even before considering immigration objectives?”
If the answer is no, the investor needs to reconsider the entire strategy.
3. EB-5: When settlement takes priority over running a business

Not every family seeking permanent residence in the United States has a business that qualifies for L-1A or EB-1C.
For some families, the primary objectives are to relocate, create opportunities for their children and build a long-term life in the United States.
In suitable circumstances, EB-5 may be an option worth evaluating.
Under the current legal framework, the minimum EB-5 investment for applications filed from 15/3/2022 is 800.000 USD for a qualifying project in a targeted employment area or a qualifying infrastructure project, and 1.050.000 USD in standard cases. These amounts are scheduled for adjustment from 2027.
Beyond the capital requirement, the program also involves conditions relating to lawful sources of funds, job creation and other application requirements.
Importantly, EB-5 should not be evaluated as a conventional investment product.
A project may meet immigration objectives without necessarily delivering attractive financial returns.
Conversely, a project with strong financial prospects may not fully meet the requirements of the EB-5 program.
Investors must assess two types of risk simultaneously: immigration risk and investment capital risk.
There is no basis for assuming that paying the full amount will guarantee a green card or the return of capital.
4. The greatest cost of a green card sometimes lies beyond the initial investment
For a family whose assets are primarily in Vietnam, the UAE or other markets, US tax obligations may be an important factor in the decision to pursue permanent residence.
Under the IRS's general rules, green card holders are considered US tax residents under the green card test, subject to specific rules on commencement, termination and potentially applicable exceptions.
US tax residents generally must report worldwide income, not only income arising in the United States.
This does not mean that all foreign income is taxed twice. Foreign tax credits, exemption provisions or tax treaties may affect the actual liability.
Nevertheless, reporting and compliance obligations can still be substantial.
Consider a hypothetical situation.
An entrepreneur has a business in Vietnam, bank accounts in Dubai and an investment portfolio spanning several countries. He wants a US green card to make it easier to visit his child at university.
If he continues to live and run his business primarily abroad, he needs to consider two issues simultaneously.
The first is whether frequent stays outside the United States are consistent with the obligation to maintain permanent resident status.
The second is the implications for taxation and reporting of international assets and accounts after becoming a US tax resident.
For someone who only wants to visit the United States a few times each year, this may represent a greater commitment than their actual needs warrant.
A long-term right of residence should not be chosen solely to address short-term travel needs.
5. A child wants to study in the United States. Do the parents necessarily need green cards?

This is one of the questions that deserves separate analysis within a global family strategy.
A family may want their child to access the US education system while the parents have no plans to relocate.
In that case, the choice of immigration status for the child and the parents' permanent residence plans need to be considered independently.
An international student can study in the United States under an appropriate visa category if eligible. Studying in the United States does not automatically require the entire family to hold green cards.
Of course, permanent resident status may offer other benefits relating to the right to live and work, as well as certain educational arrangements, depending on the state, educational institution and specific circumstances.
But these benefits need to be weighed against the costs, time, obligations and the family's actual plans.
In particular, for children approaching adulthood, application timing and rules on dependants' ages can significantly affect the strategy.
A suitable decision for the parents may not be the optimal decision for the child, and vice versa.
6. A green card grants permanent residence, not unconditional permission to live anywhere

There is an important distinction between being granted a green card and maintaining permanent resident status.
Green card holders have the right to live long-term in the United States, but maintaining this status is tied to a genuine intention to reside there.
Extended absences, establishing a principal residence abroad and related factors may trigger a review of whether a person has abandoned permanent resident status.
There is no simple formula whereby entering the United States for a few days every six months guarantees retention of a green card.
For entrepreneurs who must manage operations in Vietnam and multiple countries, this is a factor that cannot be overlooked.
A person may qualify for a green card yet not be ready to organize their life around maintaining that status.
And this is precisely when an immigration decision needs to be placed within the broader context of family, business and wealth.
7. Do not begin by asking “Which program offers the fastest route to a green card?”
Imagine three families, each with the financial capacity to pursue a US immigration program.
The first family wants to move to the United States permanently.
The second family wants to expand its Vietnamese company into the United States while keeping its operations and life primarily in Vietnam.
The third family simply wants to create additional options for their children in the future.
All three may be interested in green cards, but it should not be assumed that they need the same solution.
The first family may prioritize a permanent residence pathway suited to its circumstances.
The second family needs to begin with its business expansion strategy and an immigration status that supports actual management responsibilities.
The third family may need to evaluate timing, each member's rights and benefits, and other education or residence options before committing substantial capital.
The distinction is not about which family is wealthier.
It is about which objective needs to be addressed first.
For international entrepreneurs, having options can sometimes be more valuable than immediately holding a legal status they are not yet ready to use.
The United States remains a highly attractive market for Vietnamese businesses and families.
But accessing the US market, working in the United States and becoming a permanent resident there are decisions with different consequences.
A sound international strategy does not necessarily need to bring every family member to the same country at the same time.
It needs to create options suited to each person and each stage of life.
So, before asking which program can secure a US green card, perhaps it is better to begin with a different question:
“Do we truly want to build a life in the United States, or do we simply want the United States to be part of our family's future?”
Those two answers can lead to two very different strategies.
EMMAI GLOBAL
International Analysis & Strategy
From Vietnam to Global
This article is for reference only and does not constitute legal advice. Regulations may change.

Immigration
Golden Visa: Is long-term residence truly a safe fallback option?

Immigration
Nearly half a million dollars. Just for a driver’s license.

Family
I want to prepare the best for my children. But that does not mean they have to choose it.

Global families
How many countries does a global family need?
